Why The Super Bowl Coin Flip Prop Is The Best Bet Most Gamblers Can Make Sunday (Yes, Really)

GamingToday.com is an independent sports news and information service. GamingToday.com has partnerships with some of the top legal and licensed sportsbook companies in the US. When you claim a bonus offer or promotion through a link on this site, Gaming Today may receive referral compensation from the sportsbook company. Although the relationships we have with sportsbook companies may influence the order in which we place companies on the site, all reviews, recommendations, and opinions are wholly our own. They are the recommendations from our authors and contributors who are avid sports fans themselves.

For more information, please read How We Rank Sportsbooks, Privacy Policy, or Contact Us with any concerns you may have.

Gaming Today is licensed and regulated to operate in AZ, CO, CT, IN, LA, MI, NJ, NY, PA, TN, and VA.

'Heads' cashed in Super Bowl 45 props betting (photo by: Robin Alam/Icon Sportswire)

To the irritation of sophisticated bettors – and to those who may fancy themselves sophisticated – the Super Bowl coin flip prop is among the most popular every February. “Why would anyone, no matter how novice, risk money on something entirely random?” they ask.

Well, we’re here to tell you that betting on whether referee Ron Torbert calls “heads” or “tails” before kickoff of Rams vs. Bengals on Sunday may be the most advantageous wager most gamblers can make.

The current Super Bowl point spread at BetMGM has Rams -4.5 (-110) and Bengals +4.5 (-110). The -110 means you have to risk $110 to win $100. Same goes for the total of 44.5 – if a losing bet costs $110, the winning side pays $100.

Profiting against -110 vig requires a win percentage of 52.4. A very small percentage of bettors (1-2%) can achieve this over the long term. I am not among this elite group of gamblers; you are probably not either.

In fact, our long-term win percentage is probably right at 50% — win some, lose some — far below the sports betting Mendoza line.

Sportsbooks are dealing more favorable vig when it comes to the coin toss – much more favorable in some cases. SuperBook USA, in fact, is offering -102 on either heads or tails. Again, realistically you have a 50/50 shot to hit your Super Bowl spread bet, same as a coin flip. With a 50% chance, betting into -102 is far better than against -110.

Don’t take my word for it. Roxy Roxborough, a legendary Las Vegas bookmaker, made the same point four years ago, ahead of Eagles and Patriots in Super Bowl 52.

“I’d say that’s an astute observation by the old redhead,” Nick Bogdanovich, formerly of William Hill, said back then when I asked for his take on the notion floated by Roxy.

Still, I’m sure that you, like me, have some confidence in your handicapping abilities. So you, also like me, are probably studying up and making some plays on Sunday’s point spread, total, and a few props. Just know your sportsbook has a greater edge on Bengals +4 (-110) than it does on tails with far less juice.

Still A Pass For The Pros

Professional bettors Alan “Dink” Denkenson and Captain Jack Andrews exchanged tweets on the Super Bowl coin flip prop earlier this week. What if, Dink wondered, a sportsbook offered +101 on the prop? That would mean the edge is actually in the bettor’s favor.

Well, that’d still be a pass for Jack.

Again, Jack has an edge when he plays into -110. You don’t.

Fun With Vigorish

Scrolling through the Circa Sports app, I noticed an odds oddity. Heads is priced -104, tails -105. The respected Las Vegas book is surely weighted on “heads,” yeah?

“Surprisingly, no. A little more money and tickets on Tails,” Circa’s Chris Bennett said in a direct message.

Bettors are surely riding tails’ undeniably strong 28-27 trend over the Super Bowl’s 55-year history.

Also read: Circa’s Chris Bennett talks shop ahead of Super Bowl 56

Actually Four Ways To Bet The Super Bowl Coin Flip

FanDuel is offering not just one Super Bowl coin flip prop – it’s offering four, each priced -104 either way.

Coin Toss Result: Heads -104, Tails -104
Coin Toss Winner: Bengals -104, Rams -104
Coin Toss Call Result: Correct -104, Incorrect -104
Coin Toss Winner Wins Game: Yes -104, No -104

PlayPrintable or online Super Bowl squares | Super Bowl promos and bonuses from sportsbooks

Super Bowl propsSuperBook props extravaganza | Matthew Stafford Super Bowl props |  Cooper Kupp Super Bowl props | Ja’Marr Chase Super Bowl props | Odell Beckham Jr. Super Bowl props | Super Bowl touchdown scorer props | Plus-money Super Bowl props | Alternate Super Bowl point spreads | Super Bowl props same game parlays

Also read: Record Super Bowl handle projected | Mid-six figure Super Bowl bet at MGM | Rams-Bengals spread, moneyline, total | The case for both teams | Super Bowl parlay payouts

HistoryBiggest Super Bowl upsets | 55 years of trends

About the Author

Marcus DiNitto

Sr. News Editor
Marcus DiNitto is Senior News Editor for Gaming Today. He has been managing editor at SportsBusiness Daily, Sporting News, The Linemakers, and USA Sports Gaming. Marcus earned his MBA from the University of North Carolina-Charlotte.

Get connected with us on Social Media