Top Five Unforgettable Super Bowl Moments for Sportsbooks is an independent sports news and information service. has partnerships with some of the top legal and licensed sportsbook companies in the US. Gaming Today may receive referral compensation from the sportsbook company when you claim a bonus offer or promotion through a link on this site. Although the relationships we have with sportsbook companies may influence the order in which we place companies on the site, all reviews, recommendations, and opinions are wholly our own. They are the recommendations from our authors and contributors who are avid sports fans themselves.

For more information, please read How We Rate Sportsbooks, Privacy Policy, or Contact Us with any concerns you may have.

Gaming Today is licensed and regulated to operate in AZ, CO, CT, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, ME, MI, MS, NJ, NV, NY, OH, ON, PA, TN, VA, VT, WV, and WY.

The Super Bowl summons rich gambling memories for veteran sportsbook operators, who recall their progression through several betting eras.

That vantage point gains renewed focus, with betting already launched for Super Bowl LVIII  between the Kansas City Chiefs and San Francisco 49ers on Feb. 11. (View Super Bowl odds)

Johnny Avello, the director of race and sportsbook operations for DraftKings, has enjoyed a multi-faceted journey since the early 1980’s. He sports brick-and-mortar tenures at Bally and Wynn in Las Vegas, followed by the role in piloting DraftKings through the last five mobile wagering-enhanced Super Bowls.

Avello bridges the age of the wise guys to Mattress Mack, brick-and-mortar Las Vegas books with the national, mobile-enhanced, legal betting world. He met the gamblers face-to-face when they entered his establishments.

That camaraderie led to some of the Super Bowl wagering stories he shared this week with Gaming Today. Here’s Avello’s “Super Bowl Fab Five.”

More SB Coverage: Super Bowl Betting Apps | Super Bowl MVP Odds | Super Bowl Squares | How to Bet on Super Bowl 58

Wide Right: New York Giants 20, Buffalo Bills 19

Super Bowl 25, January 27, 1991

Avello’s book already had the Giants +6 in its pocket but as the game’s final play arrived, the Poughkeepsie, N.Y. native had a massive rooting interest. His beloved Giants would win or lose the actual game on the ensuing play.

The Bills lined up for a field goal, and Avello sought a standing-room-only view of the dramatic boot.

“I was nervous about the final play, so I stood on top of my desk to watch it,”  he recalls. “In those days, we had an office that was maybe seven feet high. It looked like the Bills were going to kick that final field goal to win, but I was hoping not.

“When Scott Norwood missed that just to the right, the Giants won the game, and I jumped up for joy. But as soon as I jumped, I hit my head pretty hard on the ceiling,” he laughed.

His headache would go away, but it lingers for the Bills. That kick is still the closest they have ever come to winning the big one.

No Safety Net: Seattle Seahawks 43, Denver Broncos 8

Super Bowl 48, Feb. 2, 2014

This time, the drama occurred on play number one. It wasn’t a good verdict for the books.

Remember the fastest score in Super Bowl history? Just 12 seconds in. It was the safety recorded by the Seahawks on the first scrimmage play on an errant snap by the Broncos. Seahawks 2, Broncos 0, Wynn Sportsbook, -$100,000 and more.

“We got dinged real badly on that one,” Avello recalls. “We had to pay the safety as the first score at 100-1. And then we had to pay for the safety in the game itself. It was a really bad break for us. We were down well into six figures, and we were just 12 seconds into the game. It happens sometimes. That put a damper on the game for us.”

That’s especially true because a gut punch like that could not be amortized over several books in many states as it would now. 

The Dream Pick: New England Patriots 28, Seattle Seahawks 24

Super Bowl 49, Feb. 1,  2015

You remember this one, the following year. The ‘Hawks were about to make it two in a row. But they passed into the end zone rather than run the winning score in from the one. Interception. The Pats steal it.

“We had a gambler make a million-dollar bet on the Patriots,” Avello remembers.  “I just happened to spot him later that night after he got paid off. What looked like a $1 million loss had suddenly become a $1 million win.

“I asked him what he liked about the game, why he put so much money on the Patriots. The guy told me he had a dream about the game.”

No handicapping. No stats. No data. It was just a dream played out in a $2 million swing.

Read More: Bill Belichick Next Team Odds | How to Bet on Super Bowl Coin Toss Odds | DK Same Game Parlay for Super Bowl 58

Patriots Rescue the Book: New England Patriots 34, Atlanta Falcon 28 (OT)

Super Bowl 51, Feb. 5, 2017

The NFL’s only overtime game became a savior for Avello just before the age of legalized gambling.

The Falcons had a 28-3 lead with 17 minutes left, and there wasn’t enough antacid in the world for Avello’s stomach.

“We had put these props up called ‘pick your own spreads,’” he said. “You could take Atlanta +3, +4, +5, etc., up to +20,” he added about a bet that was the forerunner of today’s alternate spread.

“Well, we had also had some big money on bets like Atlanta -10, Atlanta -15, and some of these were up over +240, which was for the biggest money. We also had some New England bets that would pay, so we were in this rare predicament in which we could lose all the bets.

“You know you get the feeling when there is no chance at all that you are going to win this game. I felt that way with this one, but somehow, the Patriots rallied. Because they won by six in overtime, we didn’t pay any of those big Falcons bets. That was a big break for us.”

Sacked by Mattress Mack: Tampa Bay Buccaneers 31, Kansas City Chiefs 9

Super Bowl 55, Feb. 7, 2021

DraftKings got popped on this, as Mattress Mack placed $3.75 million on Tampa Bay at +3.5. He didn’t need any of the points as this game was over by halftime for Tampa.

But with the book being in so many states, it could shake off the effect of a significant bet like this.

It’s a forerunner to the current age, in which sheer volume will absorb the shock of an occasional big-wager loss. A presence in multiple states is an insurance policy.

Avello’s big-money memories remain a link to a time when one bad bounce on one big bet could crush a book in a big game. It was a time when one book could be on the hook.

About the Author
Dave Bontempo

Dave Bontempo

Dave Bontempo is an award-winning writer and broadcaster, who has covered the sports industry since the 1970s. He won the Sam Taub Award for Excellence in Boxing Broadcasting by the Boxing Writers Association of America in 1997, and is in the New Jersey and Atlantic City Boxing Halls of Fame. Bontempo has broadcast major fights all over the world. The advent of legalized sports wagering shifted his focus to this exciting new industry in 2018.

Get connected with us on Social Media