To Top
Home » How We Rate and Review at Gaming Today

How We Rate and Review at Gaming Today

Photo of Ian St. Clair
Written by: Ian St. Clair
| |

At Gaming Today, our operator reviews are built to help you compare online gambling sites and apps and make informed decisions.

Here, we share with transparency the standards that guide our processes, the hands-on review steps we follow, the criteria we score across sportsbooks, online casinos, sweepstakes casinos, prediction markets, and more, and how we turn those findings into overall ratings and recommendations.

We also explain how we keep reviews accurate over time, what it takes for an operator to be included, and how to contact our editorial team if you spot an issue or need a correction.

The idea is to show you all the work that goes into our content so you can stay safe and have the best gaming experiences online.

Tip icon
Why trust us?
Gaming Today brings decades of credibility and independent experience to online gambling and sports betting coverage. Founded in 1976, it has maintained a long track record of reporting on the US gambling landscape. The site is supported by an expert editorial and research team with deep industry knowledge. Learn more about who is behind our site.
Visit our About Us page

Our Review Process

At Gaming Today, we follow an unbiased and consistent firsthand testing and scoring process designed to evaluate the operators we review on all fronts.

How we review operators

Steps We Take to Deliver Helpful Reviews

1

Confirm Legal Availability and Licensing

We start by confirming an operator is legally available where it offers service and that it operates under appropriate licensing and oversight. If an operator is not regulated where it operates, it does not move forward in our review process.

2

Create an Account and Verify Onboarding

Next, we go through the sign-up flow the way a real user would. We evaluate how clear the requirements are, how smooth the onboarding experience feels, and whether key information is easy to find before a player commits.

3

Make a Deposit and Test Banking Options

We then test the deposit experience by reviewing available methods, limits, and any friction in the process. Banking matters early because it affects how quickly a player can fund an account and begin using the platform.

4

Verify and Evaluate Promotions

With an account set up and funded, we review promotions in real conditions. We check offer details and key terms so readers understand what they’re getting, what it takes to qualify, and what can impact the real value of a promotion.

5

Use the Product Across Desktop and Mobile

We then evaluate the platform during real use, including usability, speed, stability, navigation, and how well key features work across desktop and mobile. This is where we assess the day-to-day experience of betting, playing, or participating in markets.

6

Test Withdrawals and Payout Experience

After use, we assess the withdrawal flow and overall payout experience by reviewing withdrawal methods, limits, and any issues that can affect how reliably a player can access funds.

7

Check Customer Support Responsiveness

We assess customer support by reviewing the channels available and how helpful and responsive support is, especially when questions involve verification, promotions, deposits, withdrawals, or account access.

8

Monitor Changes and Refresh Our Findings

Finally, we watch for changes that can affect recommendations, including product updates, offer changes, and legal availability. When something materially changes the player experience or value, we refresh our reviews and rankings to reflect the current market.

Our Rating Criteria

We prioritize operators that put player safety first. That includes operating legally where they offer service, handling customer funds responsibly, providing clear terms, and offering responsible gaming tools and resources that help players stay in control.

We evaluate how easy a platform is to use from signup to placing a bet or playing a game. We look at navigation, search and filtering, speed and stability, account management, and whether key information is easy to find without friction.

For online sportsbooks, we assess the quality and breadth of the betting menu, including major and niche markets, live betting depth, and how competitive the pricing is compared with other operators in the same state. We also consider helpful features like bet tracking, cash out, and live experience where offered.

For online casinos, sweepstakes casinos, and social casinos, we look at game variety and the quality of the experience across slots, table games, and live dealer options where available. We also consider software providers, game performance, and whether the lobby makes it easy to find the games players actually want.

For prediction markets, we evaluate what markets are available, how pricing and market depth affect the experience, and how intuitive it is to place, manage, and exit positions. We also assess whether the platform explains rules and settlement clearly so users understand how outcomes are determined.

Promotions are only valuable when they are fair and understandable. We evaluate offer value and structure, eligibility rules, and whether key terms are clearly disclosed, including wagering requirements, deadlines, exclusions, and any limits that materially affect the real-world value.

We compare deposit and withdrawal methods, minimums and maximums, fees, and the overall payout experience. Fast, reliable withdrawals matter, so we weigh both the options available and how smoothly the process works.

We assess how easy it is to get help when something goes wrong. That includes the support channels offered, responsiveness, and whether the team can resolve common issues like promo questions, verification problems, and payout delays.

Many players primarily use mobile. We evaluate app and mobile-web usability, stability, loading speed, and whether key features work as expected without glitches or missing functionality compared to desktop.

Online gambling is regulated state by state, and the experience can vary by location. We consider where an operator is available legally and how well the product, promos, and feature set match the local market and player needs.

How Our Operator Scoring Works

Gaming Today ratings are designed to answer one question: how good is this product for the player it is trying to serve?

We rate and rank operators on a 5-star scale. Our overall rating is an average of multiple category scores, and the exact mix can vary depending on what we’re reviewing, such as a sportsbook, online casino, social casino, or prediction market.

Review scoring on mobile

We rate operators by scoring the categories that matter most to the real player experience. Each category receives its own score based on our review process and rating criteria, and those scores roll up into an overall rating that reflects the full picture.

Operators that perform well across the board earn the highest ratings, while strengths in one area cannot fully offset major weaknesses in another, especially around trust, safety, and payout reliability.

What Each Rating Means

RatingWhat it means
5.0 ★★★★★Elite. A standout product that delivers an excellent experience across almost every major area. These are rare ratings reserved for products that set the standard in their category.
4.5 ★★★★⯪Excellent. One of the strongest options available. It performs at a high level overall, with only small issues or limitations keeping it from a perfect score.
4.0 ★★★★☆Very good. A reliable, above-average product with clear strengths and only a few drawbacks. Most players in its target audience should have a positive experience.
3.5 ★★★⯪☆Solid. A usable and competitive product that does the basics well, but does not separate itself much from similar options.
3.0 ★★★☆☆Fair. Meets minimum expectations, but has noticeable weaknesses in areas that affect value, convenience, trust or enjoyment.
Below 3.0 ★★☆☆☆Not recommended. Falls short of the standards we expect from products featured on GamingToday. Concerns may include unclear terms, weak support, poor usability, limited value or player-safety issues.
Tip icon
Note:
An operator must meet baseline standards to be considered in our reviews and rankings. At a minimum, it needs to be legal and appropriately regulated where it operates, provide clear terms for offers and gameplay, and deliver a functional experience that supports deposits, play, and withdrawals in a reliable way. Operators that fail these basics, or that raise serious concerns about player protection, are not included. That's why you'll rarely find anything under 3 stars on our site.

How Category Scores Become a Final Rating

After testing and research are complete, each review category receives its own score. We then calculate the overall rating by averaging those scores.

For example, a sweepstakes casino review might be scored like this:

Review CategoryScore
Bonuses and Promotions4.4
Game Variety and Quality4.1
Benefits for Existing Users3.9
Website & App Experience4.3
Security and Fairness4.0
Customer Support4.2

Total: 24.9
Number of categories: 6
Final rating: 24.9 ÷ 6 = 4.2 out of 5

This approach keeps the rating balanced. A product needs to perform consistently well to earn a high score.

How Rankings Are Updated

Online gambling changes fast. Operators update apps, expand into new states, adjust odds, rotate promotions, and modify terms. Regulatory changes and enforcement actions can also affect what’s available and how platforms operate.

When any of these shifts materially change the player experience or the value of an offer, our rankings can change with them.

Review Update Schedule

We revisit reviews and rankings on a regular basis and recheck key details that are most likely to change, especially promotions, availability by state, banking methods, and feature updates. If we see meaningful changes, we update the review to reflect the current product, not an outdated version.

When you see the “Updated” date, it signals that the review was reviewed for accuracy and refreshed to reflect the operator’s current offering. That may include updated promo terms, new features, changes in availability, or other updates that affect how we rate the operator today.

Our Standards

Gaming Today exists to be a trusted destination for sports bettors, gambling enthusiasts, and even members of the media by delivering independent reporting, analysis, and commentary informed by decades of experience covering North American sports betting and online gambling.

Responsible Gaming and Player Protection icon

Responsible Gaming and Player Protection

We take responsible gaming seriously and consider it a core part of trust. We prioritize operators that promote safer play, communicate risks clearly, and support tools that help players set boundaries and stay in control.

We look for practical safeguards that make a real difference, such as:

  • Deposit and wager limits
  • Time and session limits
  • Cooling-off options
  • Self-exclusion tools
  • Clear account controls

We also consider how easy these tools are to find and use, and whether the operator provides transparent information about how they work.

We value operators that connect players to responsible gaming resources and support options, including education, guidance, and help for those who may be experiencing gambling-related harm. We also aim to include responsible gaming information in our own coverage so readers know where to find help when they need it.

Contact Our Editorial Team icon

Contact Our Editorial Team

If you spot an error, outdated information, or something that doesn’t match your experience, we want to hear about it. Your feedback helps us keep reviews accurate and useful.

Share the page you’re referencing, what you believe is incorrect, and any details that support the correction request so our editors can review and update the information as needed.

Visit our contact page to find the official channels you can use to communicate with us.

Disclaimer

GamingToday.com publishes promotions, independent reviews, expert guides, and news about legal sports betting and gambling to help readers make informed decisions. We support responsible gambling and, where available, focus coverage on licensed and regulated operators.

Problem gambling help: call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit ncpgambling.org. 21+ only. Please play responsibly.

Affiliate disclosure: Some links may earn us compensation, at no additional cost to you. This doesn’t influence our editorial content. Offers and terms can change, always check the operator’s official terms.

Sign up to our newsletter to get GamingToday latest hands-on reviews, expert advice, and exclusive offers delivered straight to your inbox.
You are already subscribed to our newsletter. Want to update your preferences data?
Thank you for signing up! You’re all set to receive the latest reviews, expert advice, and exclusive offers straight to your inbox. Stay tuned!
Something went wrong. Please try again later