Nine Democratic U.S. senators have asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its November 5 guidance on prediction markets. They argue it could clash with state court orders and with state and tribal gambling rules.
Bloomingbit, citing The Wall Street Journal, reported that the group includes Adam Schiff, Amy Klobuchar and Elissa Slotkin. The outlet said the senators sent a letter calling on the CFTC to halt the move.
What the CFTC guidance says
Bloomingbit reported that the CFTC said on November 5 that federally regulated derivatives exchanges generally cannot restrict user access based on a customer’s state of residence. Under that interpretation, designated contract markets must remove state-by-state access limits within 30 days. Otherwise, they must explain to the CFTC why they cannot comply.
The dispute centers on whether sports- and politics-related event contracts are financial derivatives or gambling products like sports betting that are regulated by individual states. According to Bloomingbit, the CFTC treats prediction markets as federally regulated markets. The outlet also reported that the agency has sued Arkansas, arguing that state efforts to regulate CFTC-registered exchanges infringe on powers granted under federal law.
SBC Americas reported that the CFTC and the Justice Department sued both Arkansas and Louisiana over state efforts to restrict prediction markets.
Court orders and tribal lands
SBC Americas reported that Schiff’s office released the letter. The senators said the CFTC’s geofencing interpretation directly conflicts with active court orders. They said courts have ordered platforms to stop offering certain contracts in Michigan, Nevada, Washington and on the land of two California tribes.
According to SBC Americas, the CFTC issued its interpretation hours after Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley enjoined Kalshi from offering sports contracts on the lands of Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians.
The senators asked the agency to withdraw the interpretation or freeze it until litigation ends. They also asked it to confirm that court-ordered restrictions, IGRA and tribal-compact restrictions, and voluntary geographic restrictions do not violate the rule.
SBC Americas quoted Schiff’s social media reaction to the guidance. He called it “the CFTC’s most egregious attempt yet to undermine state law, the Tribes, and now, the courts.” He also wrote: “Sports prediction markets are sports bets.”
Records preservation request
The letter also asks the CFTC to preserve all records and communications related to prediction markets dating back to January 1, 2025, SBC Americas reported. The request covers personal email, mobile devices, encrypted or disappearing messaging apps, calendar entries, meeting notes, voicemail, text messages and social media. The senators asked for a response within a week confirming the agency is preserving the records.
Braden Perry, a former CFTC trial attorney and co-founding partner of Kennyhertz Perry LLC, told SBC Americas: “A letter from senators is not a subpoena, and it has no legal force on its own. But it puts the agency on notice. If records go missing later, no one at the CFTC can say they did not know to keep them.” He added: “This language reads like a first step toward something bigger.”
More from gamingtoday.com
- CFTC Access Guidance Adds Tension to Prediction Market State Restrictions
- Utah Charges Kalshi and Co-Founders as CFTC Challenges State Ban
- Sporttrade Wins CFTC Approval as Exchange and Clearinghouse
—
Sources: As reported by bloomingbit and SBC Americas.